Instacart's "Fast Delivery" launched in 2021 amid the pandemic delivery boom, targeting smaller orders customers might otherwise grab themselves.
The market quickly saturated. Amazon Fresh, Walmart Plus, DoorDash, UberEats—all promised identical speed. This sameness diminished Instacart's edge, while operational challenges further undermined its "fast" promise.
Shopper anecdotes and studies reveal grocery shopping creates surprising yet significant cognitive load. Bustling, overstimulating environments, decision fatigue, and social pressures combine to create a uniquely taxing experience where even meticulous list-makers inevitably fail.
Digital grocery interfaces add new frictions—complex navigation, substitution anxiety, and delays—merely shifting rather than solving the emotional burden.
Shoppers don't want marginally better speed; they want psychological rescue from the universal, inevitable anxiety of forgetting.
This insight guided our path to differentiation: emotional resonance rather than functional promises. By positioning Fast Delivery as emotional insurance rather than mere convenience, we could tap into primal needs for security and support.